Shuffle

T.J. Thyne

Lovell Milo

Paula Rhodes

Grace

Chris Stone

Dr. Orson Milo

Meeghan Holaway

Shelly

JoJo Henrickson

Minister

Dylan Sprayberry

Young Lovell

Elle Labadie

Young Grace

Michelle Krusiec

One night stand/Kevin's mother

Patricia Belcher

Psychiatrist

Tamara Taylor

Linda